Friday, March 24, 2017

Measuring Patient Outcomes- An Elusive Proposition?

Improving patient health has been the question that plagued the medical society for years if not decades. In fact, I dare to say, that improving patient health is the impetus of the medical community.
In our modern era, improving patient health is rapidly becoming synonym with patient outcomes. With economic concerns over cost of diagnoses, therapies and subsequent monitoring, the third-parties (governmental or private) cost reimbursements leave us scrambling to find what works and what doesn't. While articles after articles in peer-review journals and in common news outlet speaks of novel therapy or newly discovered diagnostics, the burden of new information is crippling health care professionals and/or is pigeon-holing them into a super-specialties. Furthermore, continuing education, an ethical obligation for healthcare professionals, should be designed to meet certain objectives that address performance (Moore's level 5) and patient health (Moore's level 6).
However, our poor attempt to categorize patients according to their age/gender/race and disease or attempt at bucketing diagnostics/therapies into a one group, have led to unsatisfactory results in measuring patient outcomes. At best, some were subjectives on part of the clinicians, or retrospective and anecdotal evaluation. In addition, the lack of guidance on patient outcomes measurement compound the problem even further.
What now? The question remains; how do we measure patient outcomes? This elusive endeavor can prove challenging in the modern paradigm of healthcare. Are objective biomarkers for a particular disease state a determinant of positive or negative patient outcomes? In other words, if for example we manage a patient with diabetes to attain a hemoglobin A1C below 7%, does that mean we have a positive outcome? How about that patient weight? complications? yes, I submit that the diabetic guidelines account for all of these, and perhaps on a singular patient level a clinician may have evaluated all known factors. But chasing these factors and numbers reduces the practice of medicine into a fruitless play of cat and mouse.  Healthcare practitioner after all "do not treat numbers but treat people".
Ultimately the outcomes measurement is only achievable in a holistic, multi-disciplinary approach that relies on the three main pillars of medicine: the physician, the pharmacist and the nurse. This endeavor is attainable when all three pillars are interconnected and not standing alone; physician feels safe being challenged on certain therapy choice, pharmacist welcomes the nurse's input on the patient's concern or shortcoming, and the nurse provides accurate and complete patient information and relays patient's concern to the physician. This leads me to my first proposition: there must be a genuine and complete open communication across the healthcare medium. 

However, for this communication to be successful it should be patient driven. All conversations of patient outcomes should be put aside until the patients themselves take charge. Although patient apathy is a different issue for a different discussion, recognizing the submissive, inherent attitude of patients as subordinate to their healthcare providers should be noted. Because this patient behavior is well documented in lower socioeconomic environment, special effort should not be spared in providing compatible education. Which leads me to the my second proposition: patient education material should be engaging with less text and more infographics providing the appropriate contexts.

In summary, measuring patient outcomes will continue to be elusive, but it is not illusive. It is attainable provided we approach the subject in a systematic, comprehensive way and are willing to challenge and be challenged by a new healthcare paradigm.

Wednesday, March 15, 2017

The Book of Steps or The Syriac Liber Graduum

In the past several years, when lent approaches I search for a great meditative book. My criteria are usually simple; the book should be spiritual in nature not doctrinal nor an historical exposition. I have landed on few books through the years that I seldom find myself gravitating toward again and again. Among them The Divine Ascent by St. John Climacus, On Acquisition of the Holy Spirit by St Seraphim of Sarov, Great Lent: Journey to Pascha by Alexander Schmemann, and Poverty of Spirit by Johannes Baptist Metz. This year my search took me to a book I acquired several years ago but never delved into its pages: The Book of Steps or The Syriac Liber Graduum. The book has no author because he refused to identify himself. It is a collection of about 30 sermons or as they are referred to in Syriac: mēmrē (plural of mēmrā). The edition I obtained is published by Cistercian Publications. The Syriac was translated by Robert Kitchen and Martien F.G. Parmentier with a wonderfully written introduction and notes to accompany the work.
We know that the Syriac Liber Graduum  is written at the end of the 4th century by a spiritual director (if I were to use modern terms) who had the responsibility of uplifting and caring for a flock in the northern Persian Empire. In other words, the writing has a pastoral undertone and can provide significant practical advises despite the influence of the pre-monastic, ascetic Syriac era.
In fact Kitchen and Parmentier state: "He [the author] is the pastor and teacher of a church who must tend to all of his flock, the ninety-nine and the one."
The fundamental premise of the book is to guide the ordinary laity, wealthy sponsors and the non-Christians. The mēmrē provide advises on how to attain the "Perfect" state and avoid relapsing away from it. The author identify the "Perfect" as being those who have managed to detach themselves from the world and its materials, yet still caring for the people around them. On the other hand, the "Upright" are those who, although in the world, are carrying the corporal work of mercy to their neighbors wether they deserve it or not, while those he calls "Sick" are the morally rigid and the "Children" are those who are still immature in the faith and can be easily swayed by the devil. As simplistic as this may seem, each level or state is plagued with its own temptations with all being subject to falling back and/or ascending upward to perfection. Especially those who attain the Perfect state.  In fact, toward the last few mēmrē the author reaches the conclusion that perhaps an honest "Upright" is more worthy than a hypocrite Perfect.
Perhaps the most poignant message one can gather form these sermons are their practicality and their relevance in resisting temptation and insight into human behavior vis-à-vis God and his precepts.
I never was able to "get into the book" previously despite my admiration for all things Syriac, and I think I discovered the reason. I never read the introduction and the language in the mēmrē were so foreign and seemed archaic. However, this year, I began by reading the introduction where it unravelled and "decoded" some of the language used. Here we are almost in the middle of lent, and while I have made a schedule to read one mēmrā a day, I find myself glimpsing at the next one and resisting the temptation of reading more.